US fiduciary duty rules: a Labored delivery
Seismic changes rattle the market, but structured products could stand to gain
Most annuities will be ineligible for exemptions from new fiduciary rules in the US
As hastily written rulemakings go, the US Department of Labor's (DoL) new fiduciary standards take some beating. The rules – which effectively bar intermediaries servicing retirement accounts from receiving commissions that could create a conflict of interest – were in stasis for five years amid a well-publicised spat between the DoL and the Securities and Exchange Commission.
That changed suddenly last April, when the DoL – at the behest of President Barack Obama – issued a fresh draft proposal, firing the starting gun on a year of frantic comment and redrafting before the rule's final publication on April 6 this year. The market now has a year to implement it.
The outgoing administration's efforts to railroad the rules through ahead of a regime change early next year are obvious enough. But the breakneck pace at which the rule has been drafted, and the speed at which it is expected to be implemented, has rightly set alarm bells ringing.
"Every step this DoL process has gone through, it has gone through faster than almost any other federal rule in history in light of the size and complexity of the project," Kent Mason, a partner at law firm Davis & Harman, tells Risk.net.
Seeking to protect investors is not an ignoble aim; establishing consumer confidence and trust in any market, financial or otherwise, is crucial to its healthy functioning. The trouble is that when regulators write rules in a hurry, they tend to make mistakes.
When the dust has settled, the US structured products industry might well have cause for quiet celebration; the real loser amid the changes looks set to be the US annuities market
Already, it seems certain the rules will be detrimental to clients deemed to have low dollar value that are currently serviced on a pay-as-you-go basis by brokerage accounts. These clients may be forcibly migrated to advisory accounts, raising costs for end-investors and creating operational and legal headaches for advisers, brokers say. Some may be cut off altogether.
Another knock-on effect of the rules – intentional or not – may be further consolidation among broker-dealers. "For some of the smaller commission-only brokers, the writing's probably on the wall," says one New York-based structured products lawyer. Few broker-dealers want to discuss the impact, but many privately talk of setting up dedicated "war rooms" to run through the impact of the changes on a client-by-client, account-by-account basis.
Issuers say the impact on them will ultimately depend on the number of retirement accounts in their client mix – but all are monitoring the seismic changes required within their distribution networks carefully.
Yet when the dust has settled, the US structured products industry might well have cause for quiet celebration; the real loser amid the changes looks set to be the US annuities market. While variable annuities (VAs) had long been singled out for greater scrutiny by the DoL, fixed indexed annuities (FIAs) were also caught in the final scope of the rules.
VAs and most FIAs will also be ineligible for exemptions that permit the sale of some relatively vanilla products on a commission basis under certain circumstances – arguably putting less complex structured products at an advantage when it comes to selling to retirement accounts.
The rulemaking will also subject sales of mutual funds to the same fiduciary standards – a move welcomed by the structured products industry, which has long complained that the size of the US mutual and exchange-traded funds lobbies mean they get an easier ride from regulators than equivalent rules impacting the structured products market.
As one New York-based head of structured products sales puts it: "The two main reasons people give for not buying structured products is that they are complex and include a lot of fees, yet neither of those things is true. If we have advisers that have a fiduciary duty to actually look at structured products fairly, they might realise they are a lot less complex than a VA, and way cheaper than an exchange-traded fund that will charge you 70 basis points per annum for the rest of your life."
コンテンツを印刷またはコピーできるのは、有料の購読契約を結んでいるユーザー、または法人購読契約の一員であるユーザーのみです。
これらのオプションやその他の購読特典を利用するには、info@risk.net にお問い合わせいただくか、こちらの購読オプションをご覧ください: http://subscriptions.risk.net/subscribe
現在、このコンテンツを印刷することはできません。詳しくはinfo@risk.netまでお問い合わせください。
現在、このコンテンツをコピーすることはできません。詳しくはinfo@risk.netまでお問い合わせください。
Copyright インフォプロ・デジタル・リミテッド.無断複写・転載を禁じます。
当社の利用規約、https://www.infopro-digital.com/terms-and-conditions/subscriptions/(ポイント2.4)に記載されているように、印刷は1部のみです。
追加の権利を購入したい場合は、info@risk.netまで電子メールでご連絡ください。
Copyright インフォプロ・デジタル・リミテッド.無断複写・転載を禁じます。
このコンテンツは、当社の記事ツールを使用して共有することができます。当社の利用規約、https://www.infopro-digital.com/terms-and-conditions/subscriptions/(第2.4項)に概説されているように、認定ユーザーは、個人的な使用のために資料のコピーを1部のみ作成することができます。また、2.5項の制限にも従わなければなりません。
追加権利の購入をご希望の場合は、info@risk.netまで電子メールでご連絡ください。
詳細はこちら 市場
Foreign investor hedges remain low despite US asset risks
FX hedge ratios fell to 44.5% in October with changes to US interest rates and AI stock rally
ハイパースケーラーの負債は、米国債利回りを急騰させるのか?
保険や年金基金の会社がテックの大手企業の社債に投資をシフトする中、専門家たちは金利への影響について議論しています
次世代のFX:セールス&トレーディングがAI時代へ
Claude らは、銀行が迅速なRFQやより詳細な顧客分析を実現するためのボットを構築できるよう支援しています。
マイクロソフトのシステム障害により、ストラクチャード・ノートの取引に支障が生じた
書類の多いOTCは、タームシートや取引確認書が送信トレイに滞留したことで、混乱を来しました
ディーラー各社は、中国の規制当局に対し、ISDA SIMMの承認を求めている
ISDAは、NFRAに対し、SIMMを「業界モデル」として承認するよう要請しています。
テック企業の為替ヘッジが引き続き急増している
第3四半期、アップルとマイクロンは為替取引の想定元本を60%以上引き上げた一方、アルファベットなどは純投資ヘッジのために借入金を活用しました
ゴールドマン・サックスのコモディティ部門責任者がイラン戦争から学んだこと
『トーキング・ヘッズ 2026』:価格が急騰する中、市場のヘッジは機能しなくなり、現物引き渡しが極めて重要となりました
決済の未来が形になりつつある――いくつかの大きな課題と共に
現金か暗号資産か?ネッティングの喪失にどう対処すべきか?CBDCについてはどうでしょうか?決済制度の刷新にあたり、市場には決定すべき課題が山積みです