UK and Danish greenhouse gas allowance schemes see first swap

Under the terms of the deal, brokered by Natsource Tullet Europe, Shell sold allowances created through the UK’s emissions trading scheme to Fredericia-based Elsam. In turn, Elsam sold allowances created under Denmark’s emission trading scheme to Shell. Details of the number of allowances involved and their monetary value were not released.

Denmark and the UK are the only countries to have set up government-backed emission trading schemes. The Danish scheme was set up in 2000, while the UK programme started in April 2002 – although forward transactions have been conducted since September 2001.

The swap is also significant because there is currently no regulation governing the fungibility of cross-border deals between government-mandated schemes. This means a UK allowance cannot be physically moved on to a Danish allowance account and vice versa. But both Shell and Elsam believe there is value in the scheme.

The Danish scheme places restrictions on the banking of allowances when the trading scheme ends in 2003. But UK allowances are bankable until 2007 and, with some contingencies, are also bankable into the first Kyoto Protocol compliance period of 2008-2012. So swapping Danish allowances for UK allowances allows Elsam to bank some emissions assets for future compliance periods.

For Shell, Garth Edward, trading manager, environmental products with the firm in London, said there are a number of commercial rationales for the swap. “A company that was long in the UK and is short in Denmark would be able to transfer its effective length into Denmark,” said Edward.

Shell is active in both markets, having taken on a voluntary emissions cap under the UK scheme and a mandatory cap in the Danish one.

Michael Intrator, managing director, global emissions markets at Natsource, claimed the transaction represents the future of global emissions trading. “The swap demonstrates that trades in government-backed greenhouse gas emission allowances between jurisdictions can make sense even in the absence of clear rules of fungibility. This is recognition that companies can utilise the global trading market to achieve economic and environmental objectives,” he said.

Greenhouse gases, which are mainly produced by the burning of fossil fuels to generate energy, are blamed by many scientists for the dangerous warming of the planet. Emission trading is seen by many in the industry as an efficient market-based solution to such pollution. It allows businesses to buy and sell permits that allow them to emit gases within a declining, overall limit. Energy-efficient companies can sell their unused permits to less efficient ones, thus providing a financial reward for environmental virtue.

Only users who have a paid subscription or are part of a corporate subscription are able to print or copy content.

To access these options, along with all other subscription benefits, please contact or view our subscription options here:

You are currently unable to copy this content. Please contact to find out more.

Chartis Energy50 2023

The latest iteration of Chartis' Energy50 2023 ranking and report considers the key issues in today’s energy space, and assesses the vendors operating within it

2021 brings big changes to the carbon market landscape

ZE PowerGroup Inc. explores how newly launched emissions trading systems, recently established task forces, upcoming initiatives and the new US President, Joe Biden, and his administration can further the drive towards tackling the climate crisis

You need to sign in to use this feature. If you don’t have a account, please register for a trial.

Sign in
You are currently on corporate access.

To use this feature you will need an individual account. If you have one already please sign in.

Sign in.

Alternatively you can request an individual account here