Journal of Risk Model Validation

Determination of weights for an optimal credit rating model based on default and nondefault distance maximization

Guotai Chi, Kunpeng Yuan, Ying Zhou and Lingling Gong

  • This study establishes a multi-objective function to obtain optimal indicator weights.
  • The proposed model accurately identifies default companies and nondefault ones.
  • Nonfinancial indicators have a significant effect on the credit status of Chinese SMEs.

The reasonableness of indicator weights is a key determinant of the reliability of a credit rating system. An unreliable credit rating system can lead to incorrect decisions on security investments, loan approvals and other relevant issues. Several combinations of weights are possible in such systems. Thus, it may be straightforward to determine a reasonable weight for a single indicator, but difficult to determine those for a group of indicators, and especially difficult to determine the optimal weights for such a group in a credit rating system. This study proposes a credit rating model that accurately identifies default and nondefault companies by maximizing intergroup credit score deviations and minimizing intragroup deviations. Further, this study establishes a model for determining the optimal weights for a set of indicators in a credit rating system. The empirical results show that the proposed optimal weight-based model outperforms four other weighting models (entropy weighting model, average variance weighting model, coefficient of variation weighting model and deviation weighting model). Lastly, the results show that nonfinancial indicators have a greater effect on the credit status of Chinese small and medium-sized enterprises than financial indicators do.

To continue reading...

You need to sign in to use this feature. If you don’t have a account, please register for a trial.

Sign in
You are currently on corporate access.

To use this feature you will need an individual account. If you have one already please sign in.

Sign in.

Alternatively you can request an individual account here: