Correlation between default and recovery has an important bearing on credit risk capital. Here, Rahul Sen shows that the effect can be modelled efficiently by allowing multiple loss states in the Vasicek framework. Heavy-tailed distributions result for arbitrary loss data, and simple non-parametric capital formulas apply for both large and granular portfolios
The credit component of the Basel economic capital framework is based on Vasicek's portfolio loss model (see Vasicek (2002) and Schonbucher (2000)). This is a two-state model: at the end of a given period, an obligor is placed in either a non-defaulted state or a defaulted state characterised by a fixed loss severity. Vasicek employs a Gaussian copula framework with a single common factor, the economy, accounting for correlation among obligors. As the economy varies, the portfolio default rate varies, but the loss given default (LGD) is held constant at some value Lavg regardless of the state of the economy. Typically, Lavg is set to the expected LGD (ELGD), an unconditional average over all economic states.
There is strong empirical evidence, however, that default and recovery rates both vary with the economy. Frye and others (see Frye (2005) and references therein) have argued that the constant LGD assumption is a potentially serious weakness of the Basel framework. Frye shows that coupling between default rates and LGD is pervasive across industry and debt type. To capture the higher loss rates that accompany adverse economic conditions, he suggests replacing the ELGD by a semi-empirical function of it. Another empirical suggestion is to use a 'downturn LGD', corresponding to an economic downturn. This has been criticised on the grounds that different types of portfolios respond to economic downturns with different lags (RMA Capital Working Group (2005)).
More on Credit Risk
Hedge funds target 10–12% returns on credit risk from unpaid invoices
Asean Economic Community faces challenges, says deputy governor Muhammad bin Ibrahim
Method could provide early-warning system
Kenyon and Green model the effects to pricing of credit warehousing, capital and tax
Sign up for Risk.net email alerts
Sponsored video: MarketAxess
Sponsored video: Tradeweb
Multifonds talks to Custody Risk on being nominated for the Post-Trade Technology Vendor of the Year at the Custody Risk Awards 2014
Sponsored webinar: IBM Risk Analytics
There are no comments submitted yet. Do you have an interesting opinion? Then be the first to post a comment.