27 Mar 2012, Laurie Carroll , BNY Mellon , Insurance Risk
Low interest rates are here to stay for some time, and capital preservation is front of mind. There is little yield to be had at the front end of the curve. Post-Solvency II cash will no longer be either simple or regarded as risk-free. In the view of BNY Mellon, the legislation will likely:
Essentially, there are three main facilities for managing the inventory of cash. These are: bank deposits; triple A rated money market funds; and separate accounts.
Insurers are increasingly looking at separate accounts as they have the potential to earn a higher return while still catering to the individual insurer’s liquidity needs. When examining the short- and long-term plans for the pool of cash, Solvency II subjects assets to the relevant sub-module stresses, and capital charges are calculated accordingly:
In weighing up the alternatives of bank deposits, triple A rated money market funds and separate account management, there is merit in examining the differences between the various offerings. There can be variance in credit ratings, maturities, fees and redemption costs, as well as in the legal structure and the level of transparency offered.
In seeking to mitigate risk, diversification is one of the most important considerations. Compared to a bank deposit, a potential key benefit of a money market fund and a separate account is diversification with respect to credit exposure and the type of instrument within the portfolio as well as counterparties.
With money market funds, insurers generally seek three main objectives: capital preservation (achievable through diversification), followed by liquidity and, lastly, yield. An advantage is that they are separate legal entities, ring-fenced from exposure to the sponsoring bank’s balance sheet and subject to rigorous investment guidelines and reviews by the rating agencies. Assuming that the provider of the money market fund will provide a full look-through to the underlying holdings, then these funds can be very capital-efficient for the insurer.
Spread risk and concentration risk make the largest contribution overall to the SCR. As illustrated in table A, a well-diversified money market fund provides a low capital charge. Understanding the risk profile that the look-through provisions create facilitates compatibility with an insurer’s strategic data solutions and timelines.
One method of helping achieve that diversification is to look at an insurer’s cash investment strategy as being in three buckets. For an insurer, having all their cash and cash-like investments in deposits or even money market funds over an interest rate cycle won’t provide the best outcome for a pool of cash. In a cycle of low interest rates, it is beneficial to move along the interest rate curve. In our view, having a portion of money in a liquidity fund or bank deposit, and also a portion in a separate managed account, will prove beneficial. The ‘tiering’ of cash within a separate account (essentially dividing up the pool of cash into three tiers) can provide a flexible solution, segmenting the cash for additional yield or returns (see figure 1).
The purpose of the first tier of a strategic liquidity position is to provide for day-to-day cashflows, annuity payments, or frictional trading balances for instance. A money market fund or a short-term separately managed account with customised guidelines can provide this first tier of liquidity.
The aim of the second tier is to provide for claims, debt servicing, dividends, etc., basically longer horizon cash needs. In our view, this second tier is best constructed with maturities averaging between six months and one year; enhanced cash or an ultra-short (with an average one-year maturity) separately managed account with customised guidelines would provide a solution for this need. Tier-two objectives include moderate maturity extension and focused credit guidelines against known liquidity requirements. Higher yields (reflecting the higher risk) than the first tier are to be expected.
The rationale of the third tier is for longer-term investments against matched liabilities and/ or required holdings of regulatory near-cash investments. We consider this third tier of liquidity to be best provided by a portfolio of maturities in the range one to three/one to five years or a matched-funding separately managed account with customised guidelines. Tier-three objectives entail tailored liquidity to match liabilities or one- to three-year and one- to five-year indexes and, assuming the insurer’s capital can sustain it, investment-grade credit quality. Matched funding is tailored to an insurer’s specific risk tolerance and/or cashflows, and allows flexibility for yield curve positioning.
Above all, market events, particularly in the last decade, demonstrate that investors need to take a more active role in reviewing and structuring their cash holdings to meet their liquidity needs. However, we believe investors should draw comfort from the fact that there are many more instruments and possibilities available than they may have considered to ensure their pool of cash works hard for them.
Material contained within this presentation is intended for information purposes only. It is not intended to provide professional counsel or investment advice on any matter, and is not to be used as such. No statement or expression is an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any products or services mentioned. The views expressed within this presentation are those of the author only and not those of The Bank of New York Mellon or any of its subsidiaries or affiliates, and no representation is made as to the accuracy, completeness, timeliness, merchantability or fitness for a specific purpose of the information provided in this presentation.
The views expressed herein are those of the author only and may not reflect the views of BNY Mellon. This does not constitute business or legal advice, and it should not be relied upon as such.
© Incisive Media Investments Limited 2013, Published by Incisive Financial Publishing Limited, Haymarket House, 28-29 Haymarket, London SW1Y 4RX, are companies registered in England and Wales with company registration numbers 04252091 & 04252093